Pickle Brine Margarita

Published June 7, 2024

Pickle Brine Margarita
Armando Rafael for The New York Times. Food Stylist: Cyd Raftus McDowell.
Rating
4(58)
Notes
Read community notes

Ever felt as if your margarita was missing something? Take some inspiration from Heather Rush, a co-owner and bartender at Pine Box Rock Shop, who adds pickle brine for a salty-sweet combination that’s hard to resist and delightfully umami-forward. (The bar, based in a former coffin factory in Bushwick, Brooklyn, keeps the brine on hand for another local classic: the pickleback, a shot of whiskey chased with a shot of brine.) There are plenty of ways to customize your pickle brine margarita, including a dash of habanero hot sauce or by substituting mezcal for tequila, but stick with brine from classic dill pickles, as bread and butter pickles lean too sweet. Just go easy on the salt rim; this cocktail is plenty salty on its own. For those interested in making a batch of pickle brine margaritas, see Tip. —Nikita Richardson

Learn: How to Make Cocktails

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:1 margarita
  • Ice
  • ounces reposado tequila or tequila blanco
  • 1ounce pickle brine (preferably from classic dill pickles), plus pickle chips or a pickle spear to garnish
  • 1ounce fresh lime juice, plus 1 lime wedge
  • ¾ounce triple sec (preferably Cointreau)
  • 2teaspoons granulated sugar
  • 2 to 3dashes habanero hot sauce (preferably El Yucateco), optional
  • Coarse salt, optional
Ingredient Substitution Guide

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Fill a cocktail shaker with ice.

  2. Step 2

    Add tequila, pickle brine, lime juice, triple sec, granulated sugar and hot sauce, if using. Shake until combined and foamy.

  3. Step 3

    If you’d like a salted rim for your glass, moisten the rim of a rocks glass with a lime wedge then dip it in salt to coat. Fill your glass with ice.

  4. Step 4

    Strain margarita into the ice-filled glass, garnish with pickle chips or a pickle spear, and serve immediately.

Tip
  • This recipe batches beautifully: For 8 margaritas, simply use a cup in place of every ounce (1½ cups tequila for the 1½ ounces, ¾ cup triple sec for the ¾ ounce, and so on) and ⅓ cup granulated sugar; add hot sauce to taste. Mix it all together in a large pitcher filled about halfway with ice. Be sure to stir the mixture vigorously to dissolve the sugar, and serve immediately. (You can also combine everything in a bowl or other storage container and measure out cocktails one at a time, agitating the whole mixture before adding a portion to the shaker to ensure you get an even blend of the ingredients.)

Ratings

4 out of 5
58 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

For NA folks - Topo Chico with an ounce of pickle juice, juice of half of a lime and a little tajin. A pickle spritz! So refreshing!!!

There are zero-proof tequilas, like the brand Ritual, for example. Tastes like tequila, but no alcohol :)

Ooh. That's delicious! Two thumbs up!

This was delicious and addictive. Definitely do not skip the hot sauce. I only had mezcal on hand which worked nicely.

Less than the sum of it's part. It didn't sound good, but I was curious. Don't do this to your classic margarita unless you just like to do things for the sake of novelty. Also too sweet. Thumbs down.

Also, there's no umami note in this drink. It's sour and sour and sweet and spicy.

Tajin on the rim instead of salt!!

Not what I want in a margarita, maybe if you love sour pickles but otherwise move on. Find another way to brighten up a good drink

I mix with a mild hot sauce (like Red Devil) and watermelon juice Lemon or lime juice optional. It's brilliant

Sub same amount simple syrup for granulated sugar; sub 2 tsp pickled jalapeño brine for hot sauce

Used .5 oz Ancho Reyes .25 oz agave nectar in place of the triple sec and hot pepper. Works well!

Tasty drink! Substitute agave for sugar and triple sec and ancho reyes for hot sauce.

Used same amount of simple syrup as granulated sugar. Used 2 teaspoons per drink of pickled jalapeños brine instead of hot sauce. Verdict-delicious

Just made it. I would go for less sugar, to mine I added a slice of habanero, it is a fiery treat!

This is honestly really good. Tried it with Vlasic kosher dills and Cholula’s, and it’s somewhere in the dirty martini family but south of the border.

I had my doubts about this, but was pleasantly surprised. Per some of the previous comments I used 1/2 oz simple syrup instead of granulated sugar. Everything else was according to the recipe. I loved it! The pickle brine was really pretty subtle. I did salt the rim of the glass as I do love salty things. I would definitely make this again, but I have to say it was a no-go for my husband. I guess it is personal taste. I love a really dirty martini and he most definitely does not.

This is an odd one, but I'll give it a try sans salt.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.