Sugar Cookie Bars
Margaux Laskey, “American Girl Cookies”
5312 ratings with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars
5,312
40 minutes, plus cooling
Updated Oct. 11, 2023
Advertisement
In a large saucepan, heat berries (or cherries) and sugar over medium heat (use ¾ cup sugar for cherries or blueberries, and 1 cup for raspberries or blackberries). Bring to a simmer and let cook, stirring occasionally, for 5 to 7 minutes, or until the syrup is thick and the fruit has begun to fall apart. Use a fork or potato masher to mash the fruit thoroughly.
Place a fine sieve over a bowl and strain the syrup, using a flexible spatula to push the purée through the sieve. Stir in lemon juice (or vinegar), starting with a teaspoon and adding more to taste. The syrup should be tangy-sweet.
Fill the bottoms of 4 tall glasses with syrup and stir in seltzer until the glass is two-thirds of the way full. Add scoops of ice cream to fill the glass, stir and top with whipped cream, if using. Serve immediately with a straw.
My very English grandmother's treat for me as a child, raspberry ice cream sodas, tall sloping edge glass, deep for base of stewed raspberries that had been served at breakfast, more juice than fruit; plus 3 scoops of vanilla ice cream, just classic deep tub. Then the best, the soda squirter which seemed so old fashioned, straight from 50s films. Super dessert.
For extra picturesque froth at the top, add a spoon of whipped cream in the glass before adding the seltzer.
From years of making ice cream sodas as a kid if you are after more foam (best part) the ice cream has to go in first then the soda on top. Never stir - you lose all that precious foam!
Before I saw this recipe, I made a strawberry ice cream soda with raw fruit and much less sugar. Here’s the no-recipe recipe for 2. Put about 2 big handfuls of strawberries in the blender. Add enough milk to help get the blender going - maybe a half cup. Add sugar to taste. I used about 2 heaping Tbs light brown sugar. Blend until mostly but not totally smooth. Taste and adjust as needed. Divide into 2 large glasses (about 1/3 full). Add fizzy water to 2/3 full and stir. Top with ice cream.
Club soda or unflavored sparkling/mineral water would work too.
Made as written (raspberries and vanilla ice cream) and served instead of dessert. This is good and we will add to the Fourth of July menu. The best part is the infinite ability to vary the proportions to everyone’s taste and sweetness preferences. If you make the syrup well in advance, these can be made in about 3 minutes. Make sure you chill all three ingredients in advance for a colder drink.
Blueberries and delicious, even if I kinda made blueberry jelly! Love the balsamic. So good.
We traded out the seltzer for whole milk and put it in the blender. Of course, this is now a milkshake but it was delicious, none the less!
This dessert took me immediately back to my childhood candy shop. I delightedly slurped it up. Yes!!!!
Serving this for 4th of July, using blackberry syrup. How much syrup per glass?
The berry syrup could be frozen, couldn’t it? When you have a glut of fresh fruit…..
Anyone try this with tropical fruit like chopped pineapple or mango chunks?
I strained the fruit (raspberries) so they wouldn’t get stuck in straws but saved the compote for my morning oatmeal. Another winner from M-Dawg!
The next best part of this will be using sipper straws that are also a small spoon … hard to find the days! In a previous post I called them “sipper straws and forgot the spoon part. Sorry
Made as written (raspberries and vanilla ice cream) and served instead of dessert. This is good and we will add to the Fourth of July menu. The best part is the infinite ability to vary the proportions to everyone’s taste and sweetness preferences. If you make the syrup well in advance, these can be made in about 3 minutes. Make sure you chill all three ingredients in advance for a colder drink.
I completely agree with Rosemary, don't strain the fruit, it's a lovely addition. I've also used a similar fruity syrup with just Sparkling water (flavoured water is also good) and no ice cream. A sherbet or sorbet would also be nice.
Chocolate Sodas were my favorite as a kid. Chocolate ice cream instead of vanilla with some chocolate syrup. And yes, to Rebecca, always add ice cream first for that luscious foam!! Next favorite ice cream drink - Dr. Pepper Float!
My favorite ice cream soda is to (as above) simmer some ripe peaches w/a bit of sugar. Don't strain the fruit because it's nice to be able to eat the fruit at the end w/a spoon. Instead of plain seltzer, I use one of the fierce ginger ales (like Fever Tree) and a good quality vanilla ice cream. By fierce, I'm not talking alcoholic, just strongly flavored. Something that a child would hate.
Before I saw this recipe, I made a strawberry ice cream soda with raw fruit and much less sugar. Here’s the no-recipe recipe for 2. Put about 2 big handfuls of strawberries in the blender. Add enough milk to help get the blender going - maybe a half cup. Add sugar to taste. I used about 2 heaping Tbs light brown sugar. Blend until mostly but not totally smooth. Taste and adjust as needed. Divide into 2 large glasses (about 1/3 full). Add fizzy water to 2/3 full and stir. Top with ice cream.
What's a substitute for seltzer? I'm in Ohio.
Club soda or unflavored sparkling/mineral water would work too.
We just use coke and vanilla ice cream, simple and blissful. Also called them brown cows for some reason, and orange cows if made with club orange (Irish version of Fanta)
What we called a float, usually root beer with vanilla ice cream. Yum!
Advertisement