![Carrot Cake](https://static01.nyt.com/images/2020/11/01/dining/Carrot-Cake-textless/Carrot-Cake-textless-mediumThreeByTwo440.jpg?width=1280&quality=75&auto=webp)
Carrot Cake
Dorie Greenspan
8483 ratings with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars
8,483
1 hour 30 minutes, plus at least 15 minutes' refrigeration
Published Jan. 31, 2024
Advertisement
Heat oven to 350 degrees and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
With an electric spice mill or small food processor, grind pistachios to a fine powder. (Alternatively, hand-chop pistachios; it’s OK if the result is a bit coarse.)
Place pistachio powder in a mixing bowl and stir in the almond flour, granulated sugar, cardamom and sea salt, breaking up any lumps as you go.
In a separate bowl, whisk the egg whites until frothy, then add almond extract, if using.
Combine dry ingredients and egg whites. Use a wooden spoon or hands and keep mixing until a slightly sticky dough comes together. You will think there isn’t enough liquid, but there is. (Alternatively, pulse dry ingredients and whisked egg whites in a food processor to make the dough.) The dough may be prepared and refrigerated up to 3 days ahead.
Form tablespoon-size pieces with the dough and roll between palms into spheres. (A good weight for the balls is 14 grams or ½ ounce.) Coat each well with confectioners’ sugar in a small plate, then place about 1½ inches apart on the baking sheet. Push a whole pistachio or a pinch of chopped pistachio into the center of each ball.
Bake just until very lightly browned, about 15 to 18 minutes. Remove and cool on a rack. When cool, store in an airtight tin for up to a week. They are better a bit undercooked; if baked too long, they will harden. As they cool, a thin crisp meringue-like skin forms, with a soft, moist filling.
Made these with dried, ground, leftover nuts from making my own nut milks in lieu of the almond flour and pistachios. Turned out fantastic, very quick and easy to make, good project if you have little helpers that need to be kept busy. Made half topped with pistachios, the other half with bittersweet chocolate. The cookies are tiny, so the sweetness and intense cardamom were not overwhelming. Next time, I will add orange zest!
Have not made yet, but am thinking this recipe would be great for Passover!
Absolutely delicious. Made exactly as described, using vanilla extract and baking 15 minutes. I appreciated the description for an ideal weight for each portion; it is important for this recipe. My German wife loved them!
I used a tiny ice cream scoop to portion out the 14 gram morsels, rolled them in sifted icing sugar, dusted off the tops with a brush, tossed the pistachios I was using for garnish into the bowl that held the egg whites. The small amount of egg white remaining in the bowl was enough to coat the nuts with a thin film which made them easier to adhere to the sugar dusted cookies and gave them a lovely gloss after baking.
These look like a good use for a couple of egg whites in the freezer. Although they aren't pink or red, these cookies could be part of a Valentine's Day cookie plate. Wondering whether the ingredient list should call for "whole shelled UNSALTED pistachio nuts." Pistachio flour is available from some purveyors.
Wow, for someone who loves cardamom and who tries to avoid gluten when possible, this recipe is a winner. A sublime nutty bite with complex flavor of cardamom is more than satisfying. My husband vows to take them as snack on a skiing trip instead of stale energy bars.
Orange zest is a great idea. I'll try that next. I added more cardamom I think than what it called for but it didn't overwhelm the flavor.
For those of you questioning unsalted vs salted pistachios - I used roasted salted pistachios because that’s what I had. I did skip the addition of sea salt. The cookies were very good and did not taste salty. I would probably go with raw, shelled pistachios if I had a choice, but I don’t think it makes a whole lot of difference unless you’re baking them for some high stakes baking event.
These are delicious. My dough turned out more sandy than sticky, so the cookies were very crumbly in step 6. And most of the powdered sugar was absorbed during baking. So they didn't look all that appealing, but the flavor and texture once the cookies had cooled made me not care how they looked.
These are delicious. I used 3 tsp of cardamom because we love it so much. Also I forgot to whisk the egg whites and I threw everything in the food processor after first grinding the nuts in there. Super easy (finished before the oven started preheating) and they are so good!
Really good. 23 minutes does it. I believe the photo shows larger cookies than 18 grams, and there are only 21 in the photo. So making them a bit larger doesn't hurt. I also added a combination of chocolate and butterscotch bits to the tops of some and mixed them up. You don't need to use an electric mixer. Just a good whisk and get it frothy for about 4-5 minutes.
Granddaughter and I did some Passover reconnaissance tonight. Usually make NYT almond-lemon macaroons (Almendrados) and always a hit. This is unique and delicious. Love the cardamom. No need for extracts imo. Love the idea of some orange zest. Will make both for this year’s Sedar and see if the gang has a preference.
Delicious and special. Used a combo of vanilla and almond extracts. Used freshly ground cardamom — potent! The lesser bake time of 15 minutes was plenty in my oven. Eager to make again soon.
Ground raw pistachios in Cuisinart to flour consistancy. No problem finding almond flour. Used 2.5 teaspoons of cardamon, and almond extract. Refrigerated dough for about 45 minutes; and weighed out 14 grams of dough for each cookie and ended up with 36 exactly. Forgot to set timer at 15 minutes for 1 batch and slightly undercooked them, and they were still as delicious as the rest-crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The flavors of pistachio, almond, and cardamon blended well together
Gave some to my friend and this is what she said, “cookies are so yummy! I want to hide them from my family” Thank you Mr. Tanis for sharing this recipe.
Very quick and easy cookie to bake for a Teacher Appreciation luncheon! Like others, I would like to try with orange zest next time.
Made these this afternoon. Followed recipe closely but added a tiny bit of King Arthur’s Fiori di Sicilia. Topped 1/2 with a pistachio and 1/2 with candied maraschino cherry. I think preserved amarena cherries would work, too. Both versions are delicious. I totally concur with the comment that these would be a great project with the help of young children. The dough is pretty much like a stiff playdough! Anyway, a great recipe…
I used 2/3 the sugar listed and no confectioner's sugar but still found these cloyingly sweet. If I make this again, I would cut the sugar down to half or even a quarter. Aside from that, the combination of flavors is nice.
Delicious, but much too sweet. Next time I would use about 2/3 the amount of sugar.
These are CRAZY good, wow. A bit expensive, but well worth it. And not at all difficult. Next time I think I'll give them a light egg white coating for a little more crunch on the exterior. A dark rum might be a nice sub for the almond or vanilla extract.
They were lovely as is. Next time I will cut down on sugar as I found the. A little too sweet.
I've now made 6-8 batches, taken to easter parties and sent via USPS priority to a friend recovering from surgery. I use a scale for measuring a small processor attachment to my old Osterizer and it's a fast easy assembly. Add slightly more ground cardamom and use a better quality jarred vanilla bean paste, otherwise stick to the recipe. Highly recommended!
This looks so tempting!! How can we make these eggless ?
If you use a cornstarch free powdered sugar then I think these would be a great option for Passover as macaroon type treats! There are an increasing number of these Kosher powdered sugar options on the market; for example, Simple Truth makes one, so does Wholesome and maybe O Organics or 365. You can always make your own powdered sugar starting with regular sugar too.
Easy and delish. We subbed fresh orange zest for the cardamom to give it a Sicilian flavor. Bonus - naturally g-f for all my friends who avoid gluten.
I used 1/4 cup sugar, 1 tsp cardamom, 2 tbls aquafaba in place of egg whites, and did not coat in confectioners sugar. They were delicious! Not too sweet and not too “cardamom y “ (for the person who’s not a fan). Pretty too! FYI I only got 1.5 dozen tablespoon size cookies.
i can’t stop making these - super easy and quick soo delicious ! perfect for dinner parties or taking to someone’s house as a gift. everyone who tries them loves them !
(I should add 66 g. of pasteurized egg whites = whites of two large eggs)
I made it in my large food processor. I had some leftover pasteurized egg whites and they whipped to frothy just fine. I found my teaspoon scoop came out to 14 g. (despite the description of tablespoon-sized balls). Second time I made them, I added a 1/8 tsp. rosewater along with the almond extract. Delicious.
Advertisement