Sour Pickles

Sour Pickles
Matt Roth for The New York Times
Total Time
20 minutes, plus 3 to 5 days brining
Rating
4(323)
Notes
Read community notes
  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:1 to 2 quarts
  • 2pounds freshly picked firm, unwaxed, bumpy pickling cucumbers, often called Kirby
  • 2cloves spring garlic, sliced thin (optional)
  • 1dill flower, or 5 sprigs fresh dill or 1 teaspoon dill seed (optional)
  • ½teaspoon coriander seed (optional)
  • ½jalapeño, seeded and slivered (optional)
  • 2tablespoons salt
Ingredient Substitution Guide
Nutritional analysis per serving (10 servings)

15 calories; 0 grams fat; 0 grams saturated fat; 0 grams trans fat; 0 grams monounsaturated fat; 0 grams polyunsaturated fat; 3 grams carbohydrates; 1 gram dietary fiber; 2 grams sugars; 1 gram protein; 214 milligrams sodium

Note: The information shown is Edamam’s estimate based on available ingredients and preparation. It should not be considered a substitute for a professional nutritionist’s advice.

Powered by

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Soak cucumbers for 30 minutes in a bowl filled with ice water to loosen any dirt. Slice the blossom end off each cucumber, which is opposite the stem end. If you aren’t sure which end is which, slice a little off each. Cut cucumbers into spears or chunks, if desired.

  2. Step 2

    Pack cucumbers into one or two clean quart jars. Tuck in garlic, dill, coriander and jalapeño, if using.

  3. Step 3

    Add salt to two cups boiling water. Stir until dissolved. Add two cups of ice (made with filtered water if yours is chlorinated). Stir well until the ice has melted and the brine is cool. Pour brine into jars, covering cucumbers.

  4. Step 4

    Loosely cap jars and place in a bowl or pan because the jars may leak during fermentation.

  5. Step 5

    Leave pickles on the counter to ferment. The brine will bubble lazily and become cloudy. Taste after 3 days, leaving on the counter another day or two if you want your pickles more sour, or refrigerating if they’re ready. They keep a month in the refrigerator.

Ratings

4 out of 5
323 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Too fussy and misses important points: 2T/half, 3T/full sours non-iodized table salt/qt. Convert for Kosher-it matters Just let it dissolve, no heat/ice needed Add bay, grape or black tea leaves for crunchy pickles Keep cukes submerged-above brine will mold Kahm yeast (stringy) is not harmful-remove and proceed Colored mold (fuzzy) is bad-discard. Some folks are OK w/white mold. I'm not. Don't fuss with them for the first few days-don't introduce air/bacteria Cloudy brine and sediment is OK

I've made these several times. Sometimes they're ready after two days. I cut one pickle into half-inch chunks for each jar, packing those bits in last. Sometimes that's the best way to fit the last pickle in, anyway. They become the sacrificial test pickles. Try one after two days to see if you like the pickles half-sour. (Occasionally a jar will spoil before a month, and I don't know why. Best to eat them fast!)

I made my first batch a couple of weeks ago and they came out perfect. I let them sit out on the counter for 5 days to get them nice and sour before putting them in the fridge and I just ate the last one yesterday. I'm about to make another batch tomorrow. I never knew it was so easy to make sour pickles. Awesome instructions.

Make sure you use non-iodized salt as well. Iodine will inhibit the growth of the good bacteria

Usually takes only 12- 24 hrs in mid summer in my kitchen at 75 degrees or so to see bubbles...If you have a similar environment you should get fermentation also...If not make sure you are not using tap water in any way even left over from washing cukes, dill etc...I use distilled water but most bottled water should be ok...Might try adding a bit of whey separated from plain yogurt as will speed the process...Or just put in a few drops of the liquid usually present on the top of the yogurt...

To Chris and Bonnie
I have made this recipe many times. It is excellent. I would Google the NYT article by Cathy Barrows July 10, 2013. It contains her tips not included in the recipe eg, do not use chlorinated water etc.

Made these, and bubbled/clouded as expected. However, when transferring to smaller jars for storing, noticed some pickles toward bottom of original fermenting jar had soft spots that were sort of turquoise-ish/green. What does that mean? I discarded those, but are rest safe to eat? They smell fine, no dots of mold

I've made maybe two dozen batches of these. I've gotten pretty loose about it and the results have been excellent. Recently, I made a Sichuan style pickle I learned in Carolyn Phillips' recent cookbook. You make what is called old salt water and add spices to it. Well, once those were done, there was no reason to toss the salty water, so I mixed it with the prepared salt water for these pickles. Now it seems I've um... recycled the brine a couple times and these taste better each batch.

Chris and Bonnie, Skim the “scum” off the top each day, then test a pickle piece for “doneness”.

Wish these notes about “scum” were included in the main text! Also I’d recommend submerging pickles totally, otherwise exposed tops do mold.

4th batch. 4 cups of water and 3 Tbsp of salt. Too much water. Try 3 cups next time Used 1 tsp of seasoning and 2 cloves of garlic per container. Letting sit for 4 days this time b

There are surprisingly few good pickle recipes out there. I was at first skeptical of the simplicity of this recipe, but I’ve made several batches and the pickles are superb - rivaling the best Jewish delicatessen. My modifications: 3T salt (not 2) — must be pickling salt. 4 cloves garlic (2 per quart). Add 1t peppercorns (1/2t per quart) and 1/2t mustard seed (1/4t per quart).

A favorite recipe. I add garlic scapes, split from end to end, curled into each jar along with smashed garlic cloves. Also, some typical pickling spices, like pickling spice mix. I ferment in my cellar for 5 days, checking on day 4. Darker, cooler, slower but always successful. I cover with cheesecloth so nothing gets in jar that I did not add. Enjoy!

I loved these! For me I felt there should be about 1/2 cup more ice to dilute the salt. If you do find it too salty, when you try one, just take out some of the brine and add in some more water. I am also experimenting with different herbs or spice to put in. So much easier than canning.

this is super helpful. I made two jars and one seemed super salty and I wasn't sure what to do, will add water if needed.

I doubled the salt, made our traditional recipe with sliced farm share puck E cute and refrigerated immediately.

Really easy and good. I did one batch with icing and one without (Since I was impatient) and the iced were far better. Made a big difference avoiding pouring in warm water.

I had never made pickles before making these. I left them an extra day or two and they turned out the perfect garlic dill. I used cucumbers I grew this summer. Very happy!

I've made maybe two dozen batches of these. I've gotten pretty loose about it and the results have been excellent. Recently, I made a Sichuan style pickle I learned in Carolyn Phillips' recent cookbook. You make what is called old salt water and add spices to it. Well, once those were done, there was no reason to toss the salty water, so I mixed it with the prepared salt water for these pickles. Now it seems I've um... recycled the brine a couple times and these taste better each batch.

I've read to only use UNwaxed cucumbers. But I can't find them anywhere. Must they be unwaxed, or can I just buy the Kirby cucumbers from my supermarket?

Made these, and bubbled/clouded as expected. However, when transferring to smaller jars for storing, noticed some pickles toward bottom of original fermenting jar had soft spots that were sort of turquoise-ish/green. What does that mean? I discarded those, but are rest safe to eat? They smell fine, no dots of mold

Too fussy and misses important points: 2T/half, 3T/full sours non-iodized table salt/qt. Convert for Kosher-it matters Just let it dissolve, no heat/ice needed Add bay, grape or black tea leaves for crunchy pickles Keep cukes submerged-above brine will mold Kahm yeast (stringy) is not harmful-remove and proceed Colored mold (fuzzy) is bad-discard. Some folks are OK w/white mold. I'm not. Don't fuss with them for the first few days-don't introduce air/bacteria Cloudy brine and sediment is OK

So if white fuzzy mold appears on the surface after 3 days are they bad or do you skim it off the top and eat them?

Made with organic Kirby cukes, dill flowers, split garlic scapes, peppercorns, small bay leaf, whole allspice and mustard seed. Placed, covered with gauze, in cool cellar. Refrigerated after 48 hours after tasting as bubbles and clouding began. Crispest and freshest pickles we’ve ever had but the cukes were picked same day.

This is my go-to recipe for fresh pickles. I’ve also used “pickling mix” and left the seeds in the hot pepper for more spicy brine.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.