BBQ Chicken
Sam Sifton
2542 ratings with an average rating of 4 out of 5 stars
2,542
45 minutes
Advertisement
Heat oven to 300 degrees. Combine cashews and Sriracha sauce in a small bowl and stir until nuts are coated. Line a small baking pan with foil and spread the coated cashews out on it, then place in the oven and bake until nuts are dry, approximately 20 minutes. Carefully remove the nuts from the foil and let cool, then chop roughly and set aside in a small bowl.
Meanwhile, in a large bowl, whisk together sesame oil, ½ cup soy sauce, the hoisin sauce and the black pepper, and hot sauce if using. Add chicken thighs and stir to coat. Refrigerate until ready to cook.
For the basting sauce, combine the remaining 3 tablespoons soy sauce, the brown sugar and the ginger in a small bowl, and whisk until the sugar has dissolved.
When you are ready to cook the chicken, build a fire in a charcoal grill, leaving about ⅓ of the cooking space free of coals. When coals are covered with gray ash and the temperature is medium (you can hold your hand 5 inches above the coals for 5 to 7 seconds), you are ready to cook. (For a gas grill, turn one burner to high, leaving the others off, then lower cover and heat for 15 minutes.)
Using tongs, remove chicken thighs from marinade and cook, directly over the coals, turning every few minutes, until they are well-browned but not crusty, approximately 8 to 10 minutes. Then, using a pastry brush, begin to baste them with the soy, ginger and sugar mixture, until they develop a lacquer, an additional 8 to 10 minutes, again turning every few minutes. (If chicken threatens to burn, place it over the part of the grill without coals.)
Transfer chicken to a warmed platter, sprinkle with the chopped cashews, the scallions and the cilantro, and serve.
I marinated the chicken for 2 hours and baked it in a 375 degree oven for 15 minutes on each side. Then I added the basting sauce for an additional 10 minutes. It was quite delicious with the cashews, scallions and cilantro. I served it with leftover rice and asparagus from the garden.
Can this be done in the oven? Or in a cast iron skillet on the stove top?
How long can you marinate the chicken for?
Also, for a gas grill, would you cook it on the direct heat or indirect heat?
THANKS!
Sam: For those of us apartment dwellers unable to cook this on either charcoal or gas, can we do it inside, on bake and broil, and if so -- what should we look out for?
I made this tonight in the oven. The entire Bay Area is filled with smoke from north bay wildfires, so I couldn't use my outside grill. Following suggestions from others, I baked mine at 350 degrees for about 15 minutes per side. After basting with the glaze, I broiled it for a few minutes. Turned out great. The flavors were fantastic! I plan make it again to serve at room temperature on a buffet table.
You could marinate overnight if you liked. And if cooking on a gas grill, go medium direct heat, turning often.
I would love to leave a review, but I'm so busy swooning and drooling, I'm not sure I can concentrate. I'll do my best. If this sounds good to you, make it. As soon as possible. We couldn't have loved it more--the presentation, the flavors, the tenderness of the chicken. I might use low-sodium soy next time just because I'm not a big salt eater, and I gambled with molasses and wouldn't do it any other way. So there. Sam Sifton, will you marry me?
The Sriracha roasted cashews are truly addictive, smoked paprika notches them up another level.
When my grill went kaput, I cooked the chicken on a grill pan on the stove, 7 minutes a side, then popped them into the oven at 375 for 17 minutes, then dragged 'em all back and finished them in the pan with the glaze. It wasn't the recipe, but nobody knew, and the chicken was indeed done through, delicious, and not dry.
I cooked this on a cast iron grill pan stove top. I used a little peanut oil in the pan.
I loved it, especially the Shriracha cashews.
Made this with tofu instead of chicken and in a cast-iron pan on the stove top instead of a grill. Turned out spectacularly! Added fresh habaneros to both the marinade and the basting sauce, and red miso paste to the marinade. Marinade for 1.5 hours before cooking. Served with steamed broccoli & rice, both splashed with any leftover basting sauce.
Don't have a grill so I did it in the oven (blasted it under the broiler, flipping every 5 min for about 15 min?). Also ended up with a change of plans so I ended up marinating them overnight and they still turned out great. Especially loved the sriracha nuts - listen to the headnote and definitely make a double (or quadruple!) batch. Leftovers went into fried rice (with kalbi butter) which was also insanely delish.
I marinated for two days and also baked in the oven with the marinade. Can't tell you the compliments I received! Definitely worth the effort. I served with the Mashed Potatoes with Scallions and Herbs, plating the potatoes in the middle of a large platter, surrounded by the chicken thighs. The dishes complemented one another.
Tip: After the chicken comes off the grill, squeeze half a lime over it before serving.
I cooked this on a gas grill and did exactly as the directions said. I turned the far left burner on high and the others on medium. I put the chicken on the hot left side first turning a few times. I basted once and then moved to the cooler right side as the chicken was starting to get a little crusty which you don't want. Basted and turned a few more times on the cooler side and then took it off.
Mine only marineated for about 1/2 hour and it was great.
The slightly caramelized, spicy cashews and the green onions truly leveled up this dish. Althougher pretty easy. The boneless thighs were a bit slower than anticipated on my gas grill, next time I’ll know not to rush to basting
One of the best new recipes I’ve made this year. Truly addictive! Instead of cashews, I used peanuts because I had them on hand and it gave the dish a bit more of the Vietnamese feel, it was so tasty!
Great recipe, though I modified it a bit - I had no peanuts or cashews - the scallion was great on its own. I cut down on the soy sauce and it was still quite salty. I also ommited the hot honey dressing - might do it at another time but I'm on a low/no sugar regime, felt it wasn't necessary. Also added some garlic to the marinade - the whole thing was fantastic! I think next time I might add some lime and lime zest. It was a family winner!
This was just delicious! Marinated for 2-3 hours, then grilled as instructed. The cashews, scallions and cilantro were perfect on top! Don't skip any of those. I think this would be fine with any cut of chicken - breasts would be just as tasty, and might have been less mangled than the thighs we got from Harris Teeter...
I didn't have Hoisin so I threw in some brown sugar, fish sauce and oyster sauce. My chicken thighs were small so they cooked quicker, absolutely delicious. A keeper .
Really good. I had several attempts at the coated cashews. It may have been my stove, but 300 degrees at about 20 minutes was too much, nots came out burnt. Switched to 250 degrees and they were perfect.
I cooked it in the oven and the flavor was still pretty good. Also, I replaced the sriracha sauce with gojuchang paste (and a bit of water and olive oil to dissolve the paste) and the cashews got perfectly "hot" and savory.
Bakers: Do you put the chicken directly on the sheet pan (which seems like would be a sugary nightmare to clean)? On tin foil? On parchment? On a rack?
Cooked on grill exactly to recipe...delicious! Will try as a sheet-pan bake this winter.
Made as directed in a gas grill. Delicious. Think it needs a squeeze of lime at the end but nobody was complaining as they went for seconds.
My first note of this kind. Excellent meal. Went with another note’s suggestion to bake at 375 for 18 minutes total, move to broil with marinade applied for 3 minutes. Kept all other ingredients the same. Outstanding. Thank you.
followed the sheet pan approach so a quick and easy weeknight dinner. went light on the hot sauce, siracha, and sugar, and added tofu . served over rice with baby bok choy. the flavors are awesome
This was not very flavorful. not worth it. Needs more marinating or additional flavors. Even the cashews were not that great.
Wow, absolutely delightful. Had to keep myself from snacking on the sriracha cashews while the rest of the meal was cooking. Served with mashed potatoes and green beans. Maybe the best chicken thighs I've ever had on the grill.
Are the unsalted cashews raw or roasted (before cooking)?
Advertisement