When Governor Kathy Hochul “indefinitely paused” congestion pricing, one of her reasons was a claim that the Manhattan Central Business District (CBD) hadn’t recovered post-pandemic. We looked to the traffic and speed data to see if this is true.
The fact is, New York City is experiencing the slowest travel speeds since the city started keeping track. With a deadly exception during the COVID pandemic, speeds are getting steadily slower. Today travel in the Midtown core averages less than 5 miles per hour, a 3% drop from the previous low in 2019. In the proposed congestion zone, speeds are better, but still unacceptable, averaging about 7 miles per hour, still lower than the prior low in 2019 by about 1%.
Compared with London, San Francisco, and Buffalo, rush hour travel speeds in New York City (not just the congestion zone) are 58%, 33%, and 150% slower.
![avg midtown travel speed](https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/300/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=b78744f83abab90ace6704205f1722357d15f6079529e8de3df90526e6f0774a 171w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/600/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=578179c67a12f4d6f8345d28d4bcb9d8874c9e65a3348efc06630ab6824d9e00 343w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/900/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=8671c68059fd14d650b40191002631c06bcb47b2054400ccfae53effb949c8d9 514w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1200/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=2bb71b6cd488e8e6322ecccef57ffd50b9f084993fbc04b0a0bb9f32c5ee5747 686w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1500/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=9891b7330e36772f7e77d5240478e5739a0124c120e1b495e1163e80dbb19cdd 857w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1800/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=d63b4902b0698339be56ca7f66259383b498c7f4b2dc100e8c5b99c1be9653b7 1029w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2100/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=c55b56287128dc832c002ba985cdb365ecca55e2689b24dcd427ea872428d957 1200w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2400/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=4ce367c8715a7e94da216bc9c871375e234a3773123a64ede8d2ad190abb9287 1371w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2700/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.10-PM.png?bossToken=3e2dfd9bef25e49bda9163bda81041249f859089c6a1019b44b7232e17517d74 1543w)
Taxi and FHV GPS TPEP Data - Average Midtown Travel Speed
Midtown Core
NYC DOT
![manhattan cbd travel speed](https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/300/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=ca96d0417c1d16828a3971cc5ab67161481c36825d6ac0b5e8d625dd1667789a 171w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/600/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=2441abf4fa9d6771deec1544529e9c074d14f02236487296b47e39a9c3643471 343w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/900/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=0440d0b28d6c60e78a0f99396a688c81d298013ba198c8ba595ef1b65ade7c6c 514w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1200/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=6fba419683c2b9780f279fec9eb38e2e58d7743c17904d7fa147e6c9e757cc5c 686w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1500/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=61b473f3e89648b4180a7bfdd8db7c488ffde5e7c00338796f41114a459ff01c 857w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/1800/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=f8925a0f01e71f1108f6264d5a92cf8361b7f16af3b4202ee4192c6e1480c15d 1029w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2100/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=ff84c4730a76621bc68a4b890636cbb14ad032f7af0177cd963b4c0495fac36d 1200w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2400/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=3892a38c72cc3af654226f8d18783451226fd1169e7fe9a2f95b8f87197d9abc 1371w, https://img.imageboss.me/general/width/2700/quality:80/work/Screenshot-2024-06-11-at-4.33.21-PM.png?bossToken=55a7718dcad8d01630668b8cf540961342086b3f7491e7cd5f518018d5200eee 1543w)
Taxi and FHV TPEP Data - Average Manhattan CBD Travel Speed
Manhattan CBD Core
NYC DOT
What happens when we can’t efficiently move goods and people? The Partnership for New York City estimates that we lose approximately $20B per year in lost time, productivity, and opportunity by sitting in traffic the way we do. As traffic continues to slow, those losses are magnified. And we are on a clear downward trajectory. Without common sense policy interventions such as congestion pricing to rationalize the street, or massive subway improvements which depend on congestion pricing, the only net result of this gridlock is economic, public health, and environmental damage.
The traffic increase is not hard to understand. Private automobiles coming into the CBD have reached their pre-pandemic level. The increases in home delivery precipitated by the pandemic have pushed truck traffic beyond pre-pandemic levels. The streets are full, and the only way to facilitate the regional economy is to reduce congestion and tap mass transit alternatives.
Adding capacity does not threaten the economic recovery. Rather, it is a critical strategy that fosters, nurtures, and enables economic stability.
Since most people coming to the congestion zone do so via transit, the best way to accommodate more commutes and flows of commerce into the CBD is to encourage people out of cars and into mass transit.
Immediate congestion relief is created by eliminating a relatively small percentage of vehicle trips by using a congestion charge. By using those proceeds to improve the transit experience, more riders are drawn to transit.
So much for a slow and fragile economic recovery. The reality is that we are beyond capacity on the road, and the only way out is to stop giving away the road by having drivers carry the greater cost of their travel and funneling those proceeds into mass transit investments. That sounds a lot like congestion pricing to us.
Special thanks to RPA Board Member, Sam “Gridlock Sam” Schwartz and transportation planner Kelly McGuinness for their valuable assistance in data gathering and refinement for this report.