You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.

Americans have long
prided themselves on finding rebirth
and renewal in tragedy.

#MauiStrong
#VermontStrong
#SonomaStrong
#HoustonStrong
#NOLAstrong
#FortMyersStrong

But many Americans
affected by disasters do not get
the help they need.

Opinion

America’s Disaster Recovery
System Is a Disaster

America’s Disaster Recovery System Is a Disaster

This summer, 12 people let me into their lives to tell me about their experiences in the aftermath of disasters, including hurricanes, floods, freezes, wildfires and derechos. All said, they did not receive the aid they expected, and the effects have been devastating. “It’s been a very humbling experience, to say the least, to go from ‘We’re fine, we just got a new house, we have a huge savings, biggest we’ve ever had’ to ‘You have nothing and you lost everything and you have to go to food pantries for food,’” said Aleasha LeClere, whose life was turned upside down by a 2020 derecho in Iowa. According to research on disasters and advocacy groups, these survivors’ experiences are very much the norm.

The help Americans receive after disasters isn’t just inadequate, it’s complicated to navigate and painfully slow to arrive. From the amount of time it takes to complete recovery — measured in years, not months — to the labyrinth of policies, regulations, false promises and lawsuits, the reward for surviving a disaster is being forced into a system so cruel it constitutes a second disaster.

Tessa Caudill’s eastern Kentucky home
flooded in July 2022, and at first it seemed like
the damage wasn’t too bad. But later the
wallpaper peeled off and ceilings broke away.
Tessa Caudill’s eastern
Kentucky home flooded in
July 2022, and at first it
seemed like the damage
wasn’t too bad. But later the
wallpaper peeled off
and ceilings broke away.
The money her neighbors received
from FEMA is “not a lot when
you’ve lost your home and your car,
maybe your work, your income.”
The money her
neighbors received from
FEMA is “not a lot
when you’ve lost your
home and your
car, maybe your work,
your income.”
Tessa Caudill
Whitesburg, Ky.

So few resources are available to survivors that some become homeless or live on the brink of homelessness for years, while others have no option but to continue living in their mold-filled homes. According to a 2023 survey of people in Houston, 8 percent of those experiencing homelessness cited a disaster, including Hurricane Harvey in 2017, as the cause.

The emotional toll of recovery is breaking people. Researchers have found that the circumstances of disaster recovery help to explain increases in domestic violence, a range of mental health issues, worsening physical health in people with pre-existing conditions and suicide. With climate change and its effects accelerating and intensifying, this post-disaster hell is one in which more people in more places are going to find themselves. Our system isn’t ready.

Insurance was supposed to be a safety net, but as the risks from a warming world increase from North Carolina to California, major insurers are placing new limits on the kinds of hazards they cover — or leaving altogether. Government is far from ready to make up the difference. But it needs to find a way to keep up — and get significantly more money in survivors’ hands.

The neighbors Vicki Boone and Tina George
have been trying to repair severe damages to their
homes in southwest Louisiana ever since
Hurricanes Laura and Delta came barreling
through in 2020.
The neighbors Vicki Boone
and Tina George have
been trying to repair severe
damages to their homes
in southwest Louisiana ever
since Hurricanes Laura
and Delta came barreling
through in 2020.
“I went to FEMA. FEMA was
a nightmare. They were the ones who
pretty much kept me from getting
anything because the information that
they had for me made no sense.”
“I went to FEMA.
FEMA was a nightmare.
They were the ones
who pretty much kept me
from getting anything
because the information
that they had for
me made no sense.”
Tina George (right)
Lake Charles, La.
Aleasha LeClere says she’s exhausted
from trying to recover money from insurance
companies, FEMA and other agencies
to rebuild her home in eastern Iowa after it
was damaged by the 2020 derecho.
Aleasha LeClere says
she’s exhausted from trying
to recover money from
insurance companies, FEMA
and other agencies to
rebuild her home in eastern
Iowa after it was damaged
by the 2020 derecho.
“It feels like their goal is to
break you down to the point where
you just give up and say, ‘I can’t
take it anymore,’ and I have no option.
I don’t have the money.”
“It feels like their goal is
to break you down
to the point where you just
give up and say, ‘I
can’t take it anymore,’ and
I have no option.
I don’t have the money.”
Aleasha LeClere, with
her husband, Chris LeClere
Cedar Rapids, Iowa

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.


Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT