Supported by
Sikh Separatism Is a Nonissue in India, Except as a Political Boogeyman
India’s feud with Canada highlights how Prime Minister Narendra Modi has amplified a separatist threat that in reality is largely a diaspora illusion.
![Four Sikh men, each in brightly colored turbans, sit on a wooden platform in the middle of a grassy meadow.](https://static01.nyt.com/images/2023/09/27/multimedia/00india-punjab-01-lgbj/00india-punjab-01-lgbj-articleLarge.jpg?quality=75&auto=webp&disable=upscale)
Suhasini Raj, Mujib Mashal and
Reporting from Jalandhar, in Punjab, and New Delhi
During his first trip to India as Canada’s prime minister in 2018, Justin Trudeau made a visit to the northern state of Punjab, where he got a photo op in full Punjabi dress at the Golden Temple, the holiest site of the Sikh religion.
He also got, courtesy of the Indian government, an earful of grievances — and a list of India’s most-wanted men on Canadian soil.
The killing this summer of one man on that list, Hardeep Singh Nijjar, has turned into a diplomatic war between India and Canada. Mr. Trudeau claimed this month that Indian agents had orchestrated the assassination inside Canada. India rejected the assertion and accused Canada of ignoring its warnings that Canadian Sikh extremists like Mr. Nijjar were plotting violence in Punjab in hopes of making the state into a separate Sikh nation.
But beyond the recriminations, a more complex story is unfolding in Punjab, analysts, political leaders and residents say. While the Indian government asserts that Canada’s lax attitude toward extremism among its politically influential Sikhs poses a national security threat inside India, there is little support in Punjab for a secessionist cause that peaked in deadly violence decades ago and was snuffed out.
Violence in Punjab that the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi attributes to Sikh separatists is, in fact, mostly gang-related, a chaotic mix of extortion, narcotics trafficking and score-settling. The criminal masterminds, often operating from abroad, take advantage of economic desperation in a state where farmers are crushed by rising debt and many youths lack employment or direction — problems compounded by a feeling of political alienation in minority Sikh communities.
![](https://static01.nytimes.com/newsgraphics/2023-09-28-india-punjab1-map/25fc1838-fa70-453d-b2ca-c10ff8096aa9/_assets/INDIA-PUNJAB1map-335.png)
CHINA
Amritsar
Jalandhar
Moga
PAKISTAN
PUNJAB
New Delhi
INDIA
Mumbai
300 MILES
Bay of
Bengal
Advertisement