Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT
You have a preview view of this article while we are checking your access. When we have confirmed access, the full article content will load.

Subscriber-only Newsletter

Climate Forward

The population question

Earth has reached 8 billion inhabitants. But more people doesn’t have to mean more greenhouse gas emissions.

An illustration shows two globes within the two loops of the number eight.  Within the top loop, North and South America are visible. Inside the bottom loop, South America, the South Atlantic and Africa.
Credit...The New York Times; Shutterstock

There are now 8 billion of us.

How does that affect our ability to live within planetary boundaries — and to stave off the worst climate hazards?

Actually, what matters most is not how many we are. It’s how we live.

More people doesn’t necessarily mean more emissions. More fossil fuel burning means more emissions. And more affluence has historically meant more fossil fuel burning. Take a look at the United States and India:

United States

India

The average American’s carbon emissions will still be high in 2030, despite declines.

By 2030, the average Indian’s emissions are expected to be one-fifth of an American’s.

 

Metric tons CO2-equivalent

25

25

Per-person

emissions

20

20

15

15

Projected

10

10

5

5

1990

2021

2030

2021

2030

1990

United States

The average American’s carbon emissions will still be high in 2030, despite declines.

25

Per-person

emissions

Projected

20

15

10

5 metric tons CO2-equivalent

1990

2021

2030

India

By 2030, the average Indian’s emissions are still expected to be one-fifth of an American’s.

25 metric tons CO2-equivalent per person

20

15

10

5

1990

2021

2030

United States

India

The average American’s carbon emissions will still be high in 2030, despite declines.

By 2030, the average Indian’s emissions are expected to be one-fifth of an American’s.

 

Metric tons CO2-equivalent

25

25

20

20

Per-person

emissions

15

15

Projected

10

10

5

5

1990

2021

2030

2021

2030

1990

Note: Data does not include emissions from land use and forestry.

Source: Climate Action Tracker; United Nations

By Elena Shao/The New York Times

By 2030, India’s population is projected to be more than four times that of the United States. Yet India’s total emissions are still expected to be lower than those of the United States, and its per capita emissions still a small fraction of those of the United States.

This reflects a global fact. Countries that represent 12 percent of the population account for 50 percent of the emissions that have warmed the planet over the last 170 years.

As a recent study in the journal Nature concluded, “the affluent citizens of the world are responsible for most environmental impacts” and are central to any future prospect of a more balanced relationship with the environment.

Put another way, those of us who live in the world’s richest countries consume a lot of energy. We drive long distances in big cars. We crank up the air conditioning in our offices. We eat a lot of red meat, another huge source of emissions. We throw away a lot of food. (Hacks here on fixing food waste.)

Nigeria

Germany

The average German’s emissions are much lower than an American’s, and declining.

Per-person emissions are lower still in Nigeria, despite its fast-growing population.

Metric tons CO2-equivalent

25

25

20

20

Per-person

emissions

15

15

10

10

5

5

Projected

0

0

1990

2021

2030

1990

2021

2030

Germany

The average German’s emissions are much lower than an American’s, and declining.

25 metric tons CO2-equivalent per person

20

Per-person

emissions

15

10

Projected

5

0

1990

2021

2030

Nigeria

Per-person emissions are lower still in Nigeria, despite its fast-growing population.

25

20

15

10

5

0

1990

2021

2030

Nigeria

Germany

The average German’s emissions are much lower than an American’s, and declining.

Per-person emissions are lower still in Nigeria, despite its fast-growing population.

25

Metric tons CO2-equivalent

25

20

20

Per-person

emissions

15

15

10

10

Projected

5

5

0

0

1990

2021

2030

1990

2021

2030

Note: Data does not include emissions from land use and forestry.

Source: Climate Action Tracker; United Nations

By Elena Shao/The New York Times


Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.


Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber? Log in.

Want all of The Times? Subscribe.

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT