Editor’s note: This story contains graphic language.
LAWRENCE, Kansas — Terrence Shannon Jr., the University of Illinois men’s basketball star and potential first-round pick in this month’s NBA draft, has been found not guilty of raping an 18-year-old woman in September at a bar near the University of Kansas campus.
It took a Douglas County jury — seven men and five women — about 90 minutes to reach the unanimous verdict of not guilty to one felony count of rape and to an alternative count of aggravated sexual battery, also a felony.
The 23-year-old Chicago native sat motionless next to his attorneys, Tricia Bath and Mark Sutter, as Judge Amy Hanley read the verdict.
Behind him and to his right, in a nearly full courtroom gallery, his accuser, now 19, and her friend stared forward, expressionless, while a woman to her right quietly sobbed.
Shannon’s family and friends rushed to his side after the court adjourned, hugging and celebrating the results. His mother, Treanette Redding, who sat in the front row for most of the trial, put her hands to her face as the verdict was announced, tears trickling down her cheek.
Later in the hallway, drying her tears, she said she was “relieved” by the jury’s decision.
“The accusations didn’t match the person that I raised,” Redding said. “I knew my son wasn’t capable of something like that. I’m just happy justice was served.”
Shannon left the courthouse without speaking to reporters.
Outside the courthouse, Bath said it was “a travesty that it took this long for justice to be achieved in this case. I think the jury rendered a correct verdict, but I don’t think we ever should have been here.”
Added Sutter: “Quite frankly, I think the public at large owes him an apology now. I think he took a lot of weight, took a lot of ridicule from the court of public opinion. But now that the jury of his peers have spoken, I think everyone owes him an apology.”
Prosecutors Ricardo Leal and Samantha Foster directed questions to their office’s public information officer, who asked for an emailed interview request with District Attorney Suzanne Valdez.
Earlier Thursday, Shannon took the stand on the trial’s fourth and final day and emphatically denied allegations that stem from a September trip he and two others took to Lawrence to watch an Illini-Jayhawks football game.
“I never touched, grabbed, pulled over. … I didn’t rape or sexual(ly) assault the alleged victim in this situation,” Shannon told the jury.
In his closing arguments, Senior Assistant District Attorney Ricardo Leal said the case boiled down to two college students: one, a “typical” student from a junior college who went with her friend to a bar, despite liking neither crowds nor drinking, because it’s what college students do; the other, an “atypical” star college athlete who “might as well be the king of the University of Illinois.”
“When he wants something,” Leal said, “he gets it.”
Sutter spent his closing arguments attempting to dismantle a case he called “a travesty” and a police investigation by a Lawrence police detective that Sutter said did not deserve to be called as such.
“Two things aren’t debatable,” Sutter told jurors. “Simple science dictates that Terrence Shannon Jr. isn’t responsible for this crime, and there’s been absolutely no effort to find the perpetrator guilty of this crime.”
Indeed, two jurors told the Chicago Tribune after the trial concluded that the absence of male DNA in swabs taken from the 18-year-old’s vagina and external genitals was a main factor in their decisions. “Definitely the lack of male DNA really stuck out to me,” said juror Anthony Phommaseng, 19, from Lawrence.
The jurors began deliberations just before 2 p.m. They returned with a verdict soon after 3:30 p.m.
The trial’s outcome likely will have an impact on Shannon’s fate in the NBA draft later this month. A first-team All-Big Ten selection this season and last, the fifth-year guard guided the Illini to a Big Ten Tournament championship — being named Most Outstanding Player in the process — and a trip to the NCAA Tournament’s Elite Eight, where they were trounced by eventual champion Connecticut 77-52.
The state’s case largely centered on testimony from Shannon’s accuser and her best friend, who was with her the night of the alleged encounter in a basement bar area of the Jayhawk Cafe called the Martini Room.
The 18-year-old told jurors she and her friend were heading for the exit that night when she spotted a cute boy wave her toward him. He was tall, she said, had different colored dreadlocks and wore a mustard-yellow shirt.
At her friend’s encouragement, they reentered the bar about 12:15 a.m. That’s when she said the man grabbed her and pulled her to him. She said she thought they would talk and exchange phone numbers or Snapchats. Instead, she said no words were exchanged. With a drink in one hand and a phone in the other, both arms pressed near her chest, she said she looked straight ahead as she felt the man’s hand move under her skirt to her butt.
“I was definitely uncomfortable,” she told jurors. “I don’t know why I didn’t (walk away). But I wish I did.”
Next, she said, she felt his hand move her underwear to the side and a finger inside her vagina for what she estimated to be no more than 10 seconds.
“I didn’t react,” she said. “All I did was stand there in shock.”
Black-and-white surveillance footage from the Martini Room played during the trial appeared to show Shannon and the woman moments before — but not during — the alleged encounter.
When it was over, she said, she pushed through the crowd to leave and to look for her friend. The two eventually left the bar. By then, she said, she was too hysterical to drive.
The woman said she returned to her apartment around 1:15 a.m. Saturday, and started to search for the man’s identity. She remembered that the man had been standing by a KU basketball player at the bar. She eventually identified Shannon, she said, after searching online for photos from rosters for football and basketball teams at KU and Illinois.
She did not immediately call police, she said, fighting back tears, “because I didn’t want to end up here.”
She and her friend spoke with police that same Saturday of the alleged sexual assault and then went to a Lawrence hospital, where a sexual assault nurse examination kit was collected. The two eventually returned to the Martini Room later that same night, according to testimony from a computer forensics expert who, acting on a defense subpoena, extracted data from the woman’s friend’s phone.
Phone records also showed a December group message thread involving the two women and their two other roommates, including the best friend’s sister. The exchange included a link to an ESPN article on Shannon’s suspension from the Illini men’s team following the rape charge, and a message from the friend’s sister that read “got his ass,” followed by two face emojis with dollar signs for eyes and cash for tongues.
The testimony did not mention any response from the 18-year-old to that message.
The trial saw testimony from two forensic scientists, one from the Kansas Bureau of Investigation, the other privately hired by the defense, whose analysis and interpretation of DNA in the case reached somewhat different conclusions.
Both agreed that no male DNA was detected in swabs taken from the 18-year-old’s vagina and genital area.
The KBI forensic scientist wrote in her report that swabs from the interior and exterior crotch of the woman’s underwear revealed an “insufficient amount of male DNA” to move forward with testing, though she told jurors Wednesday that those levels were essentially too low to say conclusively whether they were even DNA.
But the defense’s forensic scientist called the report’s reference to male DNA “a very misleading statement.”
Using a different measurement threshold than the KBI, the defense’s scientist also concluded “with scientific certainty” that Shannon’s DNA was not in a sample collected from the 18-year-old’s buttocks.
The lack of DNA evidence, Sutter said in closing arguments, “blows the case out of the water.”
He also chastised police for failing to interview possible witnesses and an alternative suspect who had been accused of a similar crime, two weeks earlier, in the same spot in the Martini Room where Shannon’s accuser said she was assaulted.
“This isn’t our burden,” Sutter told jurors, “and yet, after doing this case and listening to the testimony, I think you’ll all agree we proved it’s not Terrence Shannon Jr.”
